New build or resale, an honest comparison
The premium for new is real and sometimes worth it. What you actually get for it, what you give up, and the questions to ask a developer before you sign.
New construction in San Francisco commands a premium of ten to twenty percent over comparable resale. For that you get systems nobody has used, a developer warranty, modern seismic engineering, higher ceilings in the better projects, and the chance to choose finishes while they are still choices.
What you give up is proof. A resale building has a track record you can read: dues history, reserve funding, minutes, litigation, settled construction defects. A new building is a promise, and California law gives you a ten-year window on latent defects, which means the building’s real story sometimes arrives after you do.
Ask the developer four things. Who is the general contractor, and what else have they built here. What warranty structure stands behind the finishes. What is the projected HOA budget, and who funded the reserves at opening, because a new association with empty reserves is a future assessment. And what remains unsold, because a tower that is half sold a year after launch will negotiate, and one that is nearly full will not.
The sweet spot we watch is the nearly-new resale, two to five years old. The defects have surfaced and been fixed, the reserves exist, the elevator works, and the premium has deflated to nearly nothing. In the current core inventory, several of the ten sit exactly in that window, and it is not a coincidence.
Ten residences. One standard. When you are ready, the register is short on purpose.
See the Ten →